Nutty Butter

Regular price
Regular price
Sale price
Shipping calculated at checkout.

Indulge like a true foodie with Nutty Butter! This delicious treat is packed with the perfect combination of peanut butter and nutter butter cookies. Enjoy a creamy, nutty flavor in every bite!

Nutrition Facts
ChunkyFit Cookie - Nutty Butter Protein Cookie Nutrition Facts
Ingredients List

Wheat Flour, All Purpose Flour, Protein Blend (Whey, Casein) Butter, Organic Erythritol (Sugar Substitute), Organic Brown Sugar, Egg, Natural & Artificial Flavors, Lactic Acid, Calcium Propionate To Extend Freshness, Potassium Sorbate & Sodium Benzoate (Preservatives), Peanut Butter Baking Chips, Creamy Peanut Butter, Peanut Butter Cookie Pieces

Allergen Information

Contains: Wheat, Eggs, Soy, Dairy, Peanuts

Nutty Butter
Nutty Butter


What is the cookies shelf-life / expiration?

All ChunkyFit Protein Cookies are different depending on ingredients used. Our third party lab tests have given us a shelf life of 2-6 months depending on choice of flavor.

We've added an oxygen absorber in each cookie package to extend freshness and shelf-life.

Although we recommend consuming within the first 2 weeks of arrival, you may refrigerate or freeze to extend shelf-life and freshness.

How are you cookies shipped?

All cookies are shipped within 2-4 business days of purchase. Because we bake fresh weekly we make sure you're receiving the freshest possible cookie.

Because we are a small business, we cannot ship our products in climate controlled packaging as temperatures get warmer in spring/summer months.The insulation we use protects the cookies from UV rays and minimal heat, but there is always risk of certain ingredients like chocolate melting. The cookies are temperature stable, however, they will melt if left in a hot truck, warehouse, porch and/or mailbox.

You can store your cookies in the fridge for an hour to bring them back to texture if desired. We cannot control the temperature in which USPS ships so please keep an eye on your tracking number to ensure your order is not left out in the heat for a long period of time.

How to calculate net carbs of our cookies

To bake the highest quality cookie with extreme flavor our cookies use both sugars and sugar substitutes. We use a natural sugar substitute called Erythritol, so to calculate the true number of carbs in each cookie subtract 10g from the total carbohydrate number on the nutrition facts.

Customer Reviews

Based on 18 reviews
Jeremy G. (Brooklyn, US)

Nutty Butter

Roberto P. (Buena Park, US)

Nutty Butter

Anonymous (Victoria, US)
Decent alternative

Cookies are soft but eating it I wanted more flavor described from the flavor profiles. It wasn’t bad and better than many other protein cookies. Just wishing there was more for how caloric dense it is.


This thing is heavy for a cookie, good thing I'm trying to get heavy😎

Priscilla (Ontario, US)
Love love love!

These cookies taste amazing, take care of my cravings and provide me with protein, what more could I ask for!